[PDF] [arXiv]

Abstract This article investigates pathological behavior at the first limit stage in the sequence of inner mantles, obtained by iterating the definition of the mantle to get smaller and smaller inner models. I show: (A) it is possible that the $\omega$-th inner mantle is not a definable class; and (B) it is possible that the $\omega$-th inner mantle is a definable class but does not satisfy the axiom of choice. This answers a pair of questions of Fuchs, Hamkins, and Reitz.





An image from the Prose Edda, by Oluf Olufsen Bagge (1847), depecting Yggdrasil, because in this article we climb down trees to dig into the underworld. Much like with Yggdrasil in Norse myth, in this article we climb down a tree to descend into the underworld of the omega-th inner mantle.